Tuesday, July 5, 2022
The Green Market Oracle
  • Climate Change
    • Greenhouse Gas Emissions
    • Biodiversity
    • Wildfires
    • Extreme Weather
  • Energy
    • Fossil Fuels
    • Renewables
  • Politics
    • American Politics
    • Canadian Politics
    • International Politics
  • Social Change
    • Activism
    • Disinformation
    • Education
    • Psychology
    • Gender Equality
  • Business and Economics
    • Leadership
    • Decarbonization
    • Economics
    • Supply Chains
    • Investing
  • Technology
    • Carbon Removal
    • Carbon Capture
    • Transportation
    • Buildings
    • Food
No Result
View All Result
  • Climate Change
    • Greenhouse Gas Emissions
    • Biodiversity
    • Wildfires
    • Extreme Weather
  • Energy
    • Fossil Fuels
    • Renewables
  • Politics
    • American Politics
    • Canadian Politics
    • International Politics
  • Social Change
    • Activism
    • Disinformation
    • Education
    • Psychology
    • Gender Equality
  • Business and Economics
    • Leadership
    • Decarbonization
    • Economics
    • Supply Chains
    • Investing
  • Technology
    • Carbon Removal
    • Carbon Capture
    • Transportation
    • Buildings
    • Food
No Result
View All Result
The Green Market Oracle
No Result
View All Result
Home Business and Economics

Shame and Sustainability: Changing the Paradigm

by Richard Matthews
January 29, 2020
in Business and Economics, Leadership
0

Shame may be able to move us in a more sustainable direction, it may even be able to help us change the paradigm. There is reason to believe that we can leverage the little voices in our heads to do better. We may even be able to curtail our culture of over-consumption, make more responsible consumer choices, and better buying decisions.

Change is difficult but is it precisely what we need if we are to succeed in addressing the climate crisis, ecological degradation, and biodiversity loss. Superficial changes will not suffice, what we need is a cultural change and shame can play an important role. Marketers use emotional appeals to sell us things we do not need, so it is reasonable to assume that the same appeals could be used to encourage us to stop buying things we do not need.

A recent marketing study asked if shame-based advertising could increase responsible buying decisions. The researchers concluded that low-intensity guilt and shame-appeals in green advertisements do not encourage consumers to make significantly more green purchasing decisions. However, the researchers concede that further research is needed to determine whether an advertisement with more intense emotional appeals would work as a driver of sustainable consumption.

Despite the results of this study, trends in air travel give us reason to believe that this approach actually works. Flight-shaming is a growing environmental movement that is reducing the airline industry’s carbon footprint by reducing air travel. This is having a measurable impact and putting pressure on commercial air carriers pushing them to increase efficiency and purchase carbon offsets.

We need alternatives to traditional air travel. In the next couple of decades, we may have cleaner travel options like electric commercial aviation. Airships
can be almost carbon-free and while they may be ideal for some forms of freight shipping they are too slow to be a viable method of mass passenger travel.

Global air traffic is currently contributing 2.5 percent of global greenhouse gases. But air travel is expected to double to around 8.2 billion flights annually by 2037. According to a recent study by the International Council on Clean Transportation, airplane emissions are increasing much faster than forecast. The UN predicts aircraft fuel consumption will more than double by 2045.

Flight shaming me be one way that we can reduce air travel.  Flygskam is the Swedish term for flight shame, it describes the discomfort environmentally conscious people feel about commercial air travel. Flygskam was coined when the Swedish singer Staffan Lingberg pledged to give up flying. The hashtag #jagstannarpåmarken (which translates as #stayontheground) came into use around the same time.

As reported by the BBC, Sweden has seen a 4 percent drop in the number of people flying via its airports, and domestic air travel was down 9 percent. A number of people have taken the challenge of traveling without flying. More than 22,500 people have signed a pledge to go flight-free in 2020. The CEO of SAS, one of Scandinavia’s largest carriers, says that that the number of passengers is declining because of flight shaming. While air travel is declining, Sweden’s rail travel increased by at least 1.5 million tickets in 2019 compared to 2018.

According to the Guardian, surveys show a 21 percent reduction in air travel in Germany, France, the UK, and the US. The editorial concludes: “flight shame, along with movements to restrict other carbon-intensive forms of consumption, is still a force for good.”

As reviewed in a CTV article, airliners are feeling the pressure of flight-shaming. “It does seem like a switch has flipped,” says airline expert Seth Kaplan. “For a while, there was this very incremental recognition of the urgency (of climate change), and then over the past year or so all this has really gotten into the spotlight — aided by Greta Thunberg.” Greta is an internationally renowned climate activist who has spoken out about the carbon toll of air travel. She travels by electric car or train. Most recently she took a sailboat to cross the Atlantic.

The shame-based approach has been used effectively by Greenpeace to target companies. This is part of a strategy they call “market-based campaigning”. They identify problem areas, follow the supply chain, repeatedly warn and offer alternatives and if the desired response is not forthcoming they roll out a clear multipronged media campaign. The Business Insider describes what happens next as follows:

“What seems to happen, inevitably, is the multinational company, eager to remove the stigma from its signature brand, promises to ensure that its products are sustainable and begins canceling contracts with any third-party suppliers who fail to guarantee compliance. In order to retain the multinational’s lucrative business, the largest suppliers fall into line. Before long, as the cascade effect grows, they begin eyeing their wayward rivals, companies that are still operating in flagrant violation of the new rules and undercutting them with other customers. Eventually, broad new industry protocols are adopted to level the playing field.”

Shaming works and we cannot afford to be above using shame if it can help us to change our perilous trajectory.

Related

Emotion is the Key to Communicating Sustainability and Climate Messaging
The Art of Effective Science-Based Climate Communications
Sustainability as Both Sexy and Spiritual
The Pearl in the Oyster – Leveraging the Climate Crisis for Human and Planetary Health
Why We Need a New Climate Change Narrative
Overcoming Obstacles in the Creation of New Climate Narratives
Forging a New Climate Change Narrative: Addressing 5 Psychological Realities
What Beef Producers Can Teach us About Communicating Sustainability
A Marketing Guide to Selling Sustainability

ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Corruption in Washington: The Money Trail Leads to the Fossil Fuel Industry

Next Post

Greta Shines the Spotlight on Other Climate Activists

Related Posts

different types of economic systems assessed by sustainable development goals

Types of Economies and their Implications for Sustainability

by Richard Matthews
June 28, 2022
0

What are the different economic systems and what is a sustainable economy? These are important questions that need to be asked in light of the fact that the prevailing economic...

Environmental Implications of Three Types of Economies: Brown, Blue and Green

by Richard Matthews
June 3, 2022
0

Sustainable economic systems are focused on sustainable development rather than economic growth. The four types of economic systems all have environmental implications as do the three types of economies reviewed...

The 10 Colors of the Economy and Sustainable Development Goals

by Richard Matthews
April 20, 2022
0

When it comes to the economy there are many ways that we can categorize different approaches . One of the ways we can do this is through color-coding these different...

Next Post

Greta Shines the Spotlight on Other Climate Activists

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • SoundCloud

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Energy

Nuclear Energy Versus Fossil Fuels

by Richard Matthews
July 5, 2022
0

Nuclear power is garnering an increasing amount of attention as a climate-friendly energy alternative to fossil fuels which are greenhouse...

Read more
different types of economic systems assessed by sustainable development goals

Types of Economies and their Implications for Sustainability

June 28, 2022
The facts about Nuclear Energy reveal that it is safe and clean but it is not renewable

Fact Check Reveals Nuclear Energy is Safe and Clean but not Renewable

June 13, 2022

Environmental Implications of Three Types of Economies: Brown, Blue and Green

June 3, 2022

Types of Nuclear Energy: Where We Were and Where We are Today

May 31, 2022
  • About
  • Climate Change
  • Energy
  • Business and Economics
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • Social Change
  • Events
  • Other

© 2021 Copyright The Green Market Oracle.

No Result
View All Result
  • Business and Economics
    • Leadership
    • Supply Chains
  • Economics
  • Energy
    • Fossil Fuels
    • Renewables
  • Climate Change
    • Greenhouse Gas Emissions
    • Biodiversity
    • Extreme Weather
    • Wildfires
  • Investing
  • Politics
    • American Politics
    • Canadian Politics
    • International Politics
  • Technology
    • Buildings
    • Carbon Capture
    • Food
    • Transportation
  • Social Change
    • Education
    • Activism
    • Psychology

© 2021 Copyright The Green Market Oracle.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In